.
"L'art pour l'art" is French meaning "art for art's sake" ~ you may be more familiar with the Latin term "Ars gratia artis" that has been used as the slogan by Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer which appears in the circle around the roaring head of the Lion in their motion picture logo. The modern day phrase commonly used is "Arts gonna art."
.
.
.
.
The debate of the differing philosophies behind the phrases and opinions from prominent writers has been going on at least since the 1800's. You can click HERE to read an article about it on Wikipedia.
..
.
.
Basically, writers have debated the merits of poetry for poetry's sake
{ "The Poetic Principle" is an essay by Edgar Allan Poe as a literary criticism, in which Poe presents his literary theory that a poem should be written "for a poem's sake" and that the ultimate goal of art is aesthetic only, meaning the creation and appreciation of beauty. }
.
.
or if the value of art has to serve some moral or didactic purpose
{ Didacticism is a philosophy that emphasizes instructional and informative qualities in literature and other types of art. The term in its Greek origin signified learning in a fascinating and intriguing manner thus Didactic art was meant both to entertain and to instruct. }
.
.
or, indeed, the opposite that there is a responsibility to be morally subversive.
.
.
Perhaps all viewpoints are valid.
.{ "The Poetic Principle" is an essay by Edgar Allan Poe as a literary criticism, in which Poe presents his literary theory that a poem should be written "for a poem's sake" and that the ultimate goal of art is aesthetic only, meaning the creation and appreciation of beauty. }
.
.
or if the value of art has to serve some moral or didactic purpose
{ Didacticism is a philosophy that emphasizes instructional and informative qualities in literature and other types of art. The term in its Greek origin signified learning in a fascinating and intriguing manner thus Didactic art was meant both to entertain and to instruct. }
.
.
or, indeed, the opposite that there is a responsibility to be morally subversive.
.
.
Perhaps all viewpoints are valid.
.
.
.
An example of Poe's "poetry for art's sake" ~
.
Annabel Lee
by Edgar Allan Poe
.
It was many and many a year ago,
In a kingdom by the sea,
That a maiden there lived whom you may know
By the name of ANNABEL LEE;
And this maiden she lived with no other thought
Than to love and be loved by me.
Read more HERE
.
.
An example of "didactic poetry" { with a lesson in morality } might, at its simplest be ~
.
do unto others, it's true!
as you'd have them do unto you
.
for if you cause them pain
for your own selfish gain
.
karma may come around
and on your soul rebound
.
.
..
An example of Poe's "poetry for art's sake" ~
.
Annabel Lee
by Edgar Allan Poe
.
It was many and many a year ago,
In a kingdom by the sea,
That a maiden there lived whom you may know
By the name of ANNABEL LEE;
And this maiden she lived with no other thought
Than to love and be loved by me.
Read more HERE
.
.
An example of "didactic poetry" { with a lesson in morality } might, at its simplest be ~
.
do unto others, it's true!
as you'd have them do unto you
.
for if you cause them pain
for your own selfish gain
.
karma may come around
and on your soul rebound
.
.
Today's prompt is if poetry ~ and all arts ~ should be done only for arts sake..
- Write a poem for arts' sake, with no significance beyond the words on the page
- Write a didactic poem that is a conveying a moral purpose { ie: the golden rule }
- Write a morally subversive poem { ie: advocating rebellion }
- Re-write someone else's poem in the opposite style { ie: moral vs subversive }
- Write about a poet or writer who is known for her/his works which were consistently of one of these viewpoints.
- Write advocating one viewpoint or another, with your rationale.
.
Please write a new poem for this prompt; link it in with Mr. Linky; leave us a comment below; visit as many other participants as you can. { Please leave them a comment, too! }
.
I hope you can find something in this week's prompt that you want to work with.
.
Thank you for jamming with us!
.
dani
.
my heart's love songs
.
{the above images and poems are in the public domain.}</
.
I hope you can find something in this week's prompt that you want to work with.
.
Thank you for jamming with us!
.
dani
.
my heart's love songs
.
{the above images and poems are in the public domain.}</




This turned out to be a whole lot of fun...thanks so much Dani for such a fascinating prompt!
ReplyDeleteI linked mine as well tonight and will be 'visiting' as people post. Hope everyone who links a poem will also make it a point to visit others. That IS the point of the blogosphere, I think. Otherwise, why link???
ReplyDeletethank you to my fellow Jammers for their support and to everyone who participates in this prompt. if you would like, you may visit any of the first four prompts for examples.
ReplyDeletethank you and i hope you have fun!
♥
dani
oy ok, i have one up...i think i went art for arts sake...ha...it ended up feeling rather imagist, but we will see....a challenging yet fun prompt dani
ReplyDeletethanks, Brian. it was a challenge for me!!! thank you for jammin!
ReplyDeletedani
Good prompt Dani! Thanks
ReplyDeleteHi Dani! Thank you for another fun prompt--this morning another science news grabbed me--pretty soon I'm going to have to change the name of my blog...:-)
ReplyDeleteGreat prompt, Dani!!
ReplyDeleteNot sure I have interpreted it correctly, but I enjoyed doing it [wrong :-)].
ReplyDeleteMaybe over the next few days I might manage to reform this in one of the other styles.
Thanks.
Hope I have something to do here.
ReplyDeleteThanks always for your original ideas and prots and for inviting us to be a part of it
Yours
Dulce
I couldn't resist this prompt, Dani. Though my philosophy is only half-baked, I like the taste of pie-crust dough with a sprinkle of cinnamon.
ReplyDeleteWell, this is a tough one, Dani! I resurrected a poem I wrote years ago ~~~ feels brand new as I basically re-wrote it for your challenge!
ReplyDeletethank you, Helen ~ i look forward to reading it!
Delete♥
dani
thank you everyone for your kind comments and amazing poetry! it's incredible reading your words in response to my prompt.
ReplyDelete♥
dani
A really excellent prompt. Thanks for. I shall return anon to visit.
ReplyDeleteDani, You may enjoy a blog entry I wrote about my poem and this prompt. It is at "Susan, continued . . ." , my other blog: http://susan60.blogspot.com/2012/09/art-for-arts-sake-apology.html
ReplyDeletewow! for more thoughts on the "purpose" of art, read Susan's essay here:
ReplyDeletehttp://susan60.blogspot.com/2012/09/art-for-arts-sake-apology.html
thank you, Susan!
♥
Lots of fun responses to the prompt and an excellent prompt that has provoked lots of thoughtful responses.
ReplyDeleteI loved this prompt and am brand new to this site.
ReplyDeleteI wonder if it is possible to have your "Mister Linky" also list how many hours are remaining."?
Sabio ~ the Mister Linky stays open from Tuesday night until the following Tuesday morning. it's great to see you here!
ReplyDeletePeggy ~ thanks for all your support!
♥
dani